2007 - 2011 JLP in government; Written by Raliegh Barnett; Dip. Teach. BEd; MAt.

 

The Restoration of the Labor Party: Bruce Golding and the Political Realignment of 2007

Author: Raliegh Barnett, Dip Teach, BEd, M.A.T.

The 2007 General Election in Jamaica represented a historic pivot point, ending the People’s National Party’s (PNP) record-breaking eighteen-and-a-half-year hold on power. The ascension of Bruce Golding to the Office of the Prime Minister was not merely a change in administration; it was the result of a calculated structural rebranding of the Jamaica Labour Party (JLP) and an electorate suffering from systemic fatigue. This analysis examines the factors behind the 2007 transition, the subsequent "Dudus" Coke/Manatt-Phelps-Phillips crisis, and the evolving nature of governance and corruption management between Jamaica’s two primary political forces.

1. The 2007 JLP Victory: Why Bruce Golding Prevailed

Bruce Golding’s victory in 2007 was predicated on his ability to present the JLP as a modernized, technocratic alternative to a tired incumbent.

  • The "New JLP" Brand: After years of internal strife, Golding who had briefly left to form the National Democratic Movement (NDM) returned to the JLP with a "reformist" image. He successfully courted the middle class and young professionals who felt alienated by traditional "garrison" politics.

  • Economic Stagnation and Crime: By 2007, the PNP was struggling with a stagnant economy and record-high murder rates. Golding’s campaign focused on "Job Creation" and "Constitutional Reform," offering a structured roadmap that contrasted with the perceived drift of the government.

  • The Leadership Transition: The departure of the legendary P.J. Patterson left a vacuum. While Portia Simpson-Miller possessed immense grassroots charisma, the JLP effectively framed the transition as a choice between "competence" (Golding) and "popularity" (Simpson-Miller).

2. The "Ruin" of the PNP in 2007

The PNP entered the 2007 election in a state of administrative and ethical decay. After nearly two decades in power, the party faced:

  • The Trafigura Scandal: In 2006, allegations emerged regarding a $31 million donation from the Dutch oil-trading firm Trafigura Beheer to a PNP account. This scandal severely damaged the party’s moral authority and became a central pillar of the JLP’s campaign.

  • Internal Factionalism: The leadership race to succeed P.J. Patterson had left deep scars within the party. High-ranking members were divided between the "Arise and Build" and "Team Portia" camps, leading to a lack of cohesion during the general election cycle.

3. Corruption Management: PNP vs. JLP

Corruption has historically been a central theme in Jamaican political discourse, though the management styles differ:

  • The PNP Approach: Historically, the PNP has been criticized for a "protective" stance toward leadership during scandals (e.g., the Whitehouse project, the Sandals land deal, and Trafigura). However, under later leadership, the party has moved toward supporting oversight bodies like the Integrity Commission, though often after significant public pressure.

  • The JLP Approach: The JLP, particularly under Golding and later Holness, has attempted to institutionalize corruption management through "transparency" rhetoric. However, the JLP has faced its own challenges, notably the Manatt-Phelps-Phillips saga, which demonstrated that even a "reformist" government could become ensnared in the defense of political interests over national law.

4. The Manatt, Phelps, and Phillips Saga

The most significant disruption to the Golding administration was the extradition request for Christopher "Dudus" Coke.

  • The Conflict: The U.S. government requested the extradition of Coke, a powerful JLP "don," on drug and arms trafficking charges. The Golding administration initially resisted, hiring the U.S. law firm Manatt, Phelps & Phillips to lobby against the request, arguing that the evidence was obtained via illegal wiretaps.

  • The Fallout: The revelation that the JLP (and by extension the government) had sanctioned this lobbying led to a massive loss of public trust. It culminated in the 2010 Tivoli Gardens incursion, which resulted in over 70 deaths and eventually forced Bruce Golding’s resignation in 2011.

5. The 2011 Election and Governance Differences

The JLP’s loss in the 2011 election was almost entirely due to the fallout from the "Dudus" saga. Despite Andrew Holness taking over as a "clean" successor, the electorate sought to punish the party for the Tivoli incursion and the perceived protection of a criminal kingpin.

  • Difference in Governance: * JLP Governance: Often focuses on macro-economic indicators, fiscal discipline, and physical infrastructure. The "Prosperity" model relies on market stability and attracting foreign direct investment.

    • PNP Governance: Traditionally emphasizes social safety nets, human rights, and "people-centered" development. However, the lines have blurred since the 1990s as both parties now largely adhere to IMF-sanctioned fiscal frameworks.

6. Evolution: From "Third World" to "Developing State"

Jamaica has transitioned from a struggling state to one of "progressive development" through several key evolutions:

  • Fiscal Responsibility: The bipartisan commitment to the Economic Reform Programme (ERP) has seen debt-to-GDP fall from over 140% to below 80% in the last decade.

  • Digital Transformation: The shift toward an "e-governance" model and the modernization of the financial sector have increased transparency.

  • Institutional Strengthening: The establishment of MOCA (Major Organised Crime & Anti-Corruption Agency) and the independence of the Bank of Jamaica have moved the country toward a more rules-based society.

Conclusion

The 2007 election was a referendum on PNP longevity and ethical fatigue. Bruce Golding’s ability to "wrestle" power away was a triumph of rebranding, but the Manatt-Phelps-Phillips saga proved that the "old" ties of political garrisons remained a potent threat to "new" governance. Jamaica’s current trajectory suggests that while political parties may differ in their social focus, the nation has matured into a state where fiscal discipline is no longer an option, but a requirement for any party seeking to lead.

References (APA)

Golding, B. (2012). Reflections on the Tivoli Gardens Incursion. Jamaica Information Service.

Jamaica Observer. (2007, September 4). Golding Leads JLP to Victory. https://www.jamaicaobserver.com

Johnson, H. (2010). The Manatt, Phelps and Phillips Affair: A Timeline of Crisis. Caribbean Policy Research Institute (CAPRI).

The Gleaner. (2011, December 30). PNP Wins! Portia Returns as PM. https://www.jamaica-gleaner.com

Stone, C. (1980/2007 Archive). Class, Race and Political Behaviour in Jamaica. University of the West Indies Press.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

ORNAMENTAL FISH KEEPING IN JAMAICA

  Ornamental fish keeping in Jamaica   Jamaica is the home to several ornamental fish. Some of which are kept in several regions as pets. I have visited my local rivers and have seen Jaguar cichlids, called dog teeth, Goby fish, mosquito fish, guppies, mollies, fire mouth and other fish species I have no idea of their actual names. A few fish keeping enthusiast like myself has taken the initiative to catch and keep some of these list fish species as pets and in some cases have breed and sold some to local pet-shops.   The current ornamental fish trade in Jamaica is considered either un organized or top secret to all whom are looking on as a willing participant within this internationally lucrative potential economical enterprise. Many small ornamental fish keepers do exist in Jamaica. Most have entered into the trade first as a hobby and have expanded their network as a business as time progresses. To me several potentials exits for this enterprise to be streamline ...
Read more

LOOK ALIKE MBUNA CICHLIDS

  Pseudotropheus lombardoi (kenyi) mbuna cichlid and the Pseudotropheus demasoni mbuna cichlids, what is the distinct difference between the two? Both Kenyi and demasoni cichlids are African cichlids. Both are found in the lake of Malawi . To complicate matters even further the Cynotilapia afra also known in the hobby as Dog tooth cichlids do bare some resemblance when small as both. It should be noted that this fish too   is an mbuna and is also found in lake Malawi. Lets start with this cichlid, the afra cichlid or dogtooth cichlid, is a small species of cichlid fish from Lake Malawi in East Africa, where found in rocky habitats. The genus name roughly translates as dogtooth cichlid which describes the sharp, conical unicuspid teeth unique to this genus within the Lake Malawi species flock. I have never kept this fish and would love to get a few. For now I will settle with my stock of Kenyi and Demasoni. Physical description: The body is elongated and the forehead is steep...
Read more

Native aquarium fish in Jamaica

  The value of Jamaican Gully fish In Jamaica, there are several water ways. These water ways originates both naturally and conveniently by humans. These waters exist in the form of manmade gullies, water drains, streams, rivers, and to some extent man made run off ponds design to collect excess water from land during heavy rainfall. Jamaica was originally called Xaymica by its past earlier ancestors, referred to as Caribs, Arawaks and Amerindians. Prior to the discovery of the West by the Europeans, the natives of the Caribbean including Jamaica had great interest in fishing, farming and hunting. After over 400 years, fishing continues to play a significant role in both the economic as well as the natural aesthetics of Jamaica. Angling as well as net fishing facilitates the bulk of Jamaica’s fishing industry. Interestingly, ornamental fish keeping is not considered much of a value today,   yet holding superb potential especially for the export market . In Jamaica there a...
Read more